A (too) Brief Orthodox Approach to Islam
Written by Fr John Parker   
 

"God is the Lord and has revealed Himself to us, blessed is He that comes in the Name of the Lord!"  This beautiful hymn, sung at the Orthodox matins service (and a conglomeration of different Psalms) is a significant, if not the most important, starting point for our conversations about God.  When we enter a theological discussion, we do not begin with a generic belief that there is "a" God-some nameless higher power, and move from there to God's plan of salvation ultimately fulfilled in Jesus Christ.  Rather, we do and must begin with Jesus himself, God incarnate-because the Lord, He is God, and has revealed Himself by His incarnation.

At the most basic level, here is where we part significant ways with Islam-we believe that God became man.  While the Koran indicates that Jesus existed (Isa, they call Him) as the son of Mary (Miriam), and was a prophet, the Koran also seems to say that Jesus did not actually die on the cross; rather he was substituted out.  So, prophet-yes.  Man-yes.  Crucified and raised-no.

Well, to be blunt, we cannot fall into a modern day trap which venerates (somehow as co-equals) the "three Abrahamic Faiths".  "If Christ is not raised [from the dead], then our preaching is in vain and your faith is in vain".  If Jesus Christ is not the incarnate Son of God, there is no Christianity.  If He is not co-equal with the Father and the Holy Spirit, there is no Christianity.  If there is no Cross of Christ, there is no Christianity.

Still, I must fight a propensity always to linger in areas of divergence.  While we must (at some point, and with certain clarity, yet with just the right words) firmly proclaim our faith in Jesus Christ-the One who is and who was and who is to come-we must also remember that God's footprint is everywhere, as one of my friends at the OCMC (http://www.ocmc.org/) Fr David Rucker always reminds me.  Wherever there is good, there is God, because God alone is good.  Where there is beauty, God is there, because He is the source of beauty.  Where there is generosity, God is there because he is the font of mercy.  Where there is order and discipline, God is there, because He is Order.  These aspects of God and of true life can be found, sometimes in seed form, sometimes in flower, in Islam and Islamic culture.

So, we must be glad that the Koran proclaims that God is merciful.  Here we can agree.  But we must at some point ask one another what mercy is.  For us, the definition of mercy is Christ crucified-and raised.  We must rejoice that the Koran recognizes that Jesus was born of Mary, and that he was a prophet.  The Scriptures are clear on this.  Even the woman at the well cried out, "I see, sir, that you are a prophet!"  But sometime and somehow we must ask the question, "What is a prophet?"  At the most basic level, a prophet is one who speaks the truth-especially about God.  So, if Jesus made statements equating himself to God (everytime he said "I AM"-unfortunately translated "It is I" in the Gospels, He equated Himself to God who told Moses "I AM sent you".), he would also be either delusional (if He didn't know what He was saying) or a liar (if He did).  In either case, why follow a deluded individual or a liar?

We must also rejoice that Muslims seem to take their faith very, very seriously.  St Paul's words come to mind-"I see that you are a religious people!"  We, in totally honest fact, are put to shame by their ascetic disciplines-7 times of devoted prayer daily, strict adherence to their fasting, almsgiving, hospitality, pilgrimage, and fierce battle against the riptide of secularism.  In these areas especially, we would do well to imitate them in their outward efforts-our own, of course, rooted specifically, intentionally, and absolutely in Jesus Christ.

While we certainly lament (weak word choice) Islamic extremists, we must certainly recognize that we have our own Orthodox Christian fundamentalists, and certainly self-proclaimed non-Orthodox fundamentalist Christians-folks who bomb abortion clinics and kill abortion doctors come to mind.  What we must ultimately seek and address is the truth, and be conformed to it-or rather to Him.  If we would but take this step seriously-all of us Orthodox Christians-our ‘battle' would be a much easier one, because the Truth of our faith would shine in deeds, not just words.

Comments (2)Add Comment
Biggest threat to Christians is not Islam, but rather to the lack of cohesion within Christianity itself
written by James Alexandros Papastamos, September 02, 2008
As your article states, followers of Islam outwardly demonstrate their faith and conviction. Within Christianity, faith has become "politically incorrect". This is entirely the fault of the baby boomer generation of the post war years. We had raised our material standard of living such that this generation became pre-occupied with the physical world, decidedly neglecting the metaphysical. God is beyond physical. The baby boomers were the first of the "me first" generation: self centred, agnostic, morally bankrupt and spiritually empty men and women whose definition of freedom is "if it feels good, do it."
The next big problem is the existence of numerous denominations. The Orthodox Church and Catholic Church are authentic; the Protestant church has turned out to be the biggest joke on the planet. The fact that the Protestant church focuses soley on holy scripture, choosing to neglect holy tradition, has resulted in the growth of various sects within Protestant Christianity itself, where different people interpret the holy scriptures in different ways. Think about it: anglican, methodist, presbyterian, pentacostal, baptist, jehovas witness, mormon. Why are there so many sects within this branch of Christianity.
Unless Christians unite, Islam will devour us. This is the biggest threat to Christians. We live in a cultural and social dark age, despite all the technological advances. What good is material progress if there is no moral progress to accompany it? What good is scientific progress without social progress? The two go hand in hand.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: -1
The show also overlooked another major topic
written by gchancy, September 03, 2008
The Father interviewed in the piece talked about the threat of fundamentalism, and indicated that most Muslims are not fundamentalist and, therefore, are not much of a threat. This is true and false at the same time.

The major threat people associate with Islam is that Muslims will blow things up or riot. While these things do occur, they are not that common. Most Muslims are not prone, especially when living in the West, to violence. However, fundamentalist or not, a majority of Muslims take for granted that within society the Muslims should be given the top positions, and Dhimmi should have only the rights accorded them in the Koran.

This accounts for why Muslims in Britain, for example, demand compliance by the non-Muslims with Muslim law. It also accounts for why Muslim societies have been unable to achieve full equality. Law and governance are conjoined with religion in the mindset of the majority of Muslims. To be a citizen of a Muslim state, one must be a Muslim. Non-Muslims simply don't get the protections of full citizenship.

This is a major issue, and one which the father simply did not address. By its structure, Islam has proven incapable of creating a dynamic in which citizenship and full human rights is available by separating citizenship from religion. This is not just a fundamentalist issue, as all Muslim-majority states suffer from this to more or less degrees, whether Dubai or Saudi Arabia or Pakistan.
report abuse
vote down
vote up
Votes: +1

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
smile
wink
laugh
grin
angry
sad
shocked
cool
tongue
kiss
cry
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
< Prev   Next >